Flexibility provision through enhanced synergies between electricity, gas and heat systems: a comparative analysis of market and regulatory frameworks in seven case study countries
- Author(s): Lionel Cauret 1 ; Regine Belhomme 1 ; Pauline Raux-Defossez 2 ; Stanislas Nösperger 3 ; Johannes Steinbeisser 4 ; Juana Pagán Carpe 4
-
-
View affiliations
-
Affiliations:
1:
EDF, Research & Development , Palaiseau , France ;
2: EIfER Europäisches Institut für Energieforschung , Karlsruhe , Germany ;
3: Efficacity , Champs-sur-Marne , France ;
4: Regenera Levante S.L. , Murcia , Spain
-
Affiliations:
1:
EDF, Research & Development , Palaiseau , France ;
- Source:
Volume 2, Issue 2,
June
2020,
p.
133 – 143
DOI: 10.1049/iet-esi.2019.0062 , Online ISSN 2516-8401
This is an open access article published by the IET and Tianjin University under the Creative Commons Attribution -NonCommercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/)
Received
28/06/2019,
Accepted
02/02/2020,
Revised
21/09/2019,
Published
21/02/2020

Full text loading...
/deliver/fulltext/iet-esi/2/2/IET-ESI.2019.0062.html;jsessionid=9zkmb35438af.x-iet-live-01?itemId=%2fcontent%2fjournals%2f10.1049%2fiet-esi.2019.0062&mimeType=html&fmt=ahah
Inspec keywords: heat systems; renewable energy sources; organisational aspects
Other keywords: regulatory frameworks; flexibility provision; energy sectors; electricity system; multienergy systems; market organisations; renewable energy sources; MAGNITUDE European project; heat sectors; heat systems; MES; gas systems; gas sectors; enhanced synergies
Subjects: Energy resources; Energy resources and fuels; Energy and environmental policy, economics and legislation; Power system management, operation and economics
References
-
-
1)
-
14. Sandberg, E., Kilkerud, J., Tromborg, E., et al: ‘Energy system impacts of grid tariff structures for flexible power-to-district heat’, Energy, 2019, 168, pp. 772–781.
-
-
2)
-
30. Torbaghan, S., Virag, A., Le Cadre, H., et al: ‘D3.3 – specification of the multi-energy market simulator’, MAGNITUDE, 2019.
-
-
3)
-
51. European Union, DIRECTIVE 2009/73/EC of 13 July 2009 concerning common rules for the internal market in natural gas and repealing Directive 2003/55/EC’, European Union, Brussels, 2009.
-
-
4)
-
31. EU-SysFlex: ‘EU-SysFlex H2020 European project -Pan-European system with an efficient coordinated use of flexibilities for the integration of a large share of RES’, 2018. Available at http://eu-sysflex.com/. EU-SYSFLEX project, 2018. Available at https://eu-sysflex.com/ (accessed 2019).
-
-
5)
-
2. Gabrielli, P., Gazzani, M., Martelli, E., et al: ‘Optimal design of multi-energy systems with seasonal storage’, Appl. Energy, 2018, 219, pp. 408–424.
-
-
6)
-
53. European Commission, ‘Quarterly Report on European Gas Markets, Market Observatory for Energy, Volume 11, issue 4, fourth quarter of 2018’, European Commission, Brussels, 2018.
-
-
7)
-
39. RTE Réseau de transport d’électricité, French electricity Balancing roadmap: green paper, RTE, La Défense, 2016.
-
-
8)
-
17. ENTSOE: ‘Survey on ancillary services procurement, balancing market design 2016’, 2017, Brussels.
-
-
9)
-
55. Energimarknadsinspektionen (Swedish Energy Markets Inspectorate): ‘The Swedish electricity and natural gas market 2018’ (Swedish Energy Markets Inspectorate, Eskilstuna, 2019).
-
-
10)
-
56. UK Energy research Centre: ‘Flexibility in Great Britain's gas networks: analysis of linepack and linepack flexibility using hourly data’ (UK Energy Research Centre (UKERC), London, 2019).
-
-
11)
-
42. ENERGINET: ‘Technical conditions for participating in automatic balancing in Denmark’, Frederica, 2016.
-
-
12)
-
38. Commission de Régulation de l'Energie, Roadmap on French electricity, CRE, Paris, 2017.
-
-
13)
-
1. Bloess, A., Schill, W., Zerrahn, A.: ‘Power-to-heat for renewable energy integration: a review of technologies’, Appl. Energy, 2018, 212, pp. 1611–1626.
-
-
14)
-
65. Holzleitner, M., Moser, S.: ‘Energy efficiency in the district heating: an analysis of the renewable energy directive regarding alternative feed-in options’. ECEEE Summer Study Proc., Belambra Presqu'île de Giens, France, 2019, pp. 891–898.
-
-
15)
-
18. EU-SYSFLEX: ‘State-of-the-art literature review of systems scarcities at high levels of renewable generation’, EU-SYSFLEX, 2018.
-
-
16)
-
49. EURACTIV: ‘The evolving role of gas storage in Europe’, EURACTIV, 17 May 2019. Available at https://www.euractiv.com/section/energy/news/the-evolving-role-of-gas-storage-in-europe/ (accessed May 2019).
-
-
17)
-
23. Hu, J., Harmsen, R., Crijns-Graus, W., et al: ‘Identifying barriers to large-scale integration of variable renewable electricity into the market: a literature review of market design’, Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev, 2018, 81, pp. 2181–2195.
-
-
18)
-
70. E-Control: ‘E-Control Regulation Commission OrdinanceSettingthe Electricity System Charges (Electricity System Charges Ordinance 2018)’, 2018. [En ligne]. Available at https://www.e-control.at/documents/20903/443907/SNE-V_2018+_2017-11-29+final_en.pdf/de2d5753-781a-f4ef-c019-0453ffdcda4e (accessed 26 June 2019).
-
-
19)
-
19. SmartNet: ‘Ancillary service provision by RES and DSM connected at distribution level in the future power system’, 2016.
-
-
20)
-
52. ENERGINET, Emergency plan – Energinet rules for gas transport, Doc.18/03267-13, page 9, ENERGINET, Fredericia, 2018.
-
-
21)
-
10. Zhong, W., Xie, K., Yang, C., et al: ‘Auction mechanisms for energy trading in multi-energy systems’, IEEE Trans. Ind. Inf., 2018, 14, (4), pp. 1511–1521.
-
-
22)
-
6. Schweiger, G., Rantzer, J., Ericsson, K., et al: ‘The potential of power-to-heat in Swedish district heating systems’, Energy, 2017, 137, pp. 661–669.
-
-
23)
-
25. MAGNITUDE Consortium: ‘MAGNITUDE – bringing flexibility provided by multi energy carrier integration to a new MAGNITUDE’. Available at https://www.magnitude-project.eu/ (accessed 2019).
-
-
24)
-
13. Bergaentzlé, C., Jensen, I., Skytte, K., et al: ‘Electricity grid tariffs as a tool for flexible energy systems: a Danish case’, Energy Policy, 2019, 126, pp. 12–21.
-
-
25)
-
12. Skytte, K., Olsen, O., Soysal, E., et al: ‘Barriers for district heating as a source of flexibility for the electricity system’, J. Energy Markets, 2017, 10, (2), pp. 1–19.
-
-
26)
-
54. European Commission, ‘Quo vadis EU gas market – Study on a Gas Market Design for Europe’, European Commission, Brussels, 2018.
-
-
27)
-
7. Yilmaz, H.Ü., Keles, D., Chiodi, A., et al: ‘Analysis of the power-to-heat potential in the european energy’, Energy Strategy Rev., 2018, 20, pp. 6–19.
-
-
28)
-
34. OFGEM: ‘Decision: Default tariff cap – Overview document’, OFGEM, London, 2018.
-
-
29)
-
60. SNCU (French Syndicate of District Heating Operators): ‘Enquête nationale sur les réseaux de chaleur et de froid’, 2017.
-
-
30)
-
68. TemaNord for Nordic Energy Regulators, Demand-side flexibility in the Nordic electricity market: from a distribution system operator perspective, Nordic Council of Ministers, 2017.
-
-
31)
-
22. EU-SYSFLEX Project: ‘Models for simulating technical scarcities on the European power system with high levels of renewable generation’, 2018.
-
-
32)
-
20. Smart Energy Demand Coalition (SEDC): ‘Explicit demand response in Europe: mapping the markets 2017’, Brussels, 2017.
-
-
33)
-
4. Mancarella, P.: ‘MES (multi-energy systems): an overview of concepts and evaluation models’, Energy, 2014, 65, pp. 1–17.
-
-
34)
-
48. Stopa, J., Kosowski, P.: ‘Underground gas storage in EUROPE – energy safety and its cost’. 27th World Gas Conf., Washington, 2018.
-
-
35)
-
29. Kessels, K., Torbaghan, S., Virag, A., et al: ‘Evaluation of future market designs for multi-energy systems’, 2019. Available at https://www.magnitude-project.eu/.
-
-
36)
-
63. Werner, S.: ‘District heating and cooling in Sweden’, Energy, 2017, 126, (1), pp. 419–429.
-
-
37)
-
66. Dansk Energi: ‘Mulighederne for den fremtidige fjernvarmeproduction i decentrale områder’, Analyse, n° %19, 2013.
-
-
38)
-
32. MIGRATE H2020 European project: ‘Deliverable D1.1: Report on systemic issues’, 2016.
-
-
39)
-
57. ORSTED: ‘Europe powered by green energy, how the north seas can lead the change’ (ORSTED, Gentofte, 2017).
-
-
40)
-
35. European Commission: ‘Final report of the sector inquiry on capacity mechanisms’, European Commission, Brussels, 2016.
-
-
41)
-
24. POYRY and Imperial College: ‘Roadmap for flexibility services to 2030: report to the committee on climate change’, 2017.
-
-
42)
-
9. Kessels, K., Leclercq, G., Sels, P., et al: ‘Innovative market schemes for integrated for integrated multi-energy systems’. Int. Conf. on the European Energy Market (EEM), Ljubljana, Slovenia, 2019.
-
-
43)
-
27. Li, H., Nookuea, W., Campana, P., et al: ‘Cartography of the flexibility services provided by heating/cooling, storage and gas technology and systems to the electricity system’, 2019. Available at https://www.magnitude-project.eu/.
-
-
44)
-
67. Raux-Defossez, P., Pétillon, D., Bialecki, A., et al: ‘Grid services provided by the interactions of energy sectors in multi-energy systems: three international case studies’, Chez Energy Proc., 2018, 15, pp. 209–227.
-
-
45)
-
15. Skytte, K., Bergaentzlé, C., Fausto, F.J., et al: ‘Flexible nordic energy systems: Policy brief – key recommendations’ Project Flex4RES (Nordic Energy Research, Oslo, Norway, 2019).
-
-
46)
-
36. Commission de Régulation de l'Electricité et du Gaz (France), Roadmap on French electricity balancing, CRE, 2017.
-
-
47)
-
21. EU-SysFlex: ‘Product definition for innovative system services’. EU-SYSFLEX, 2019.
-
-
48)
-
46. The Carbon Trust for BEIS: ‘Evidence Gathering – Low Carbon Heating Technologies: domestic hybrid heat pumps’, BEIS, London, 2016.
-
-
49)
-
45. Element Energy Limited for Department BEIS: ‘Hybrid heat pumps: final report’, Element Energy, Cambridge, 2017.
-
-
50)
-
44. ENTSOE: ‘Explanatory document to all TSOs’ proposal for the implementation framework for a European platform for the exchange of balancing energy from frequency restoration reserves with automatic activation (online)’, 2018. Available at https EBGL/EBGL_A21_181218_ALL%20TSOs%20proposal_aFRRIF_explanatory_document_for%20submission.pdf?Web=0 (accessed 2019).
-
-
51)
-
28. Pini, N., Witkowski, K., Seidelt, S., et al: ‘Technology and case studies factsheets’, 2019. Available at https://www.magnitude-project.eu/.
-
-
52)
-
47. IEA Annex 45 Working Group from the Technology Collaboration Program on Heat Pumping Technologies: ‘Hybrid heat pumps: IEA HPT Annex 45 Final report’, 2019.
-
-
53)
-
58. Mi, J., Khodayar, M.: ‘Operation of natural gas and electricity networks with line pack’, J. Mod. Power Syst. Clean Energy, 2019, 7, (5), pp. 1056–1070.
-
-
54)
-
16. Flex4RES: ‘Framework conditions for flexibility in the district heating-electricity interface’, Flexible Nordic Energy Systems, 2016.
-
-
55)
-
64. Boldt, J.: ‘The district heating system in greater Copenhagen area – in a free power market’. Chez EnergyLab Nordhavn Seminar, Nordhavn, 2018.
-
-
56)
-
33. Conseil d'Etat, République Française: ‘Décisision du Conseil d'Etat sur les tarifs réglementés de vente d’électricité’, 2018, Paris.
-
-
57)
-
8. ERA-Net Smart Energy Systems: ‘Innovation for smart energy systems in Europe’, 2019. Available at https://www.eranet-smartenergysystems.eu/ (accessed 2019).
-
-
58)
-
40. Neuhoff, K., Hobbs, B., Newbery, D.: ‘Congestion Management in European Power Networks: Criteria to Assess the Available Options’, DIW, Berlin, 2011.
-
-
59)
-
37. European Commission: ‘COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) 2017/2195 of 23 November 2017 establishing a guideline on electricity balancing’, European Commission, Brussels, 2017.
-
-
60)
-
3. Zheng, J., Zhou, Z., Zhao, J., et al: ‘Effects of the operation regulation modes of district heating system on an integrated heat and power dispatch system for wind power integration’, Appl. Energy, 2018, 230, pp. 1126–1139.
-
-
61)
-
43. ENTSOE: ‘Consultation on the design of the platform for automatic Frequency Restoration Reserve (aFRR) of PICASSO region (online)’, 2017. Available at https://www.entsoe.eu/network_codes/eb/picasso/ (accessed 2019).
-
-
62)
-
26. Cauret, L., Belhomme, R., Raux-Defossez, P., et al: ‘Benchmark of markets and regulations for electricity, gas and heat and overview of flexibility services to the electricity grid’, 2019. Available at https://www.magnitude-project.eu/.
-
-
63)
-
5. Mancarella, P., Andersson, G., Peca-Lopes, J., et al: ‘Modelling of integrated multi-energy systems: drivers, requirements, and opportunities (Invited Paper)’. 19th Power Systems Computation Conference (PSCC) 2016, Genoa, Italy, 2016.
-
-
64)
-
50. Cornot-Gandolphe, S.: ‘Ten major trends in the European gas market’, CEDIGAZ, Rueil Malmaison, 2018.
-
-
65)
-
59. Schwele, A., Ordoudis, C., Kazempour, J., et al: ‘Coordination of power and natural gas systems: convexification approaches for linepack modeling’. Proc. IEEE PES PowerTech 2019, Milano, Italy, 2019.
-
-
66)
-
61. Swedish Energy Agency, ‘Energy in Sweden’, 2016.
-
-
67)
-
62. Dansk Fjernvarme (Danish District Heating association): ‘Statistics about District Heating’, 2017[En ligne]. Available at https://www.danskfjernvarme.dk/english/statistics (accessed November 2018).
-
-
68)
-
41. ENTSOE: ‘Impact of merit order activation of automatic frequency restoration reserves and harmonised full activation times’, Brussels, 2015.
-
-
69)
-
11. Yazdani-Damavandi, M., Neyestani, N., Shafie-khah, M., et al: ‘Strategic behavior of multi-energy players in electricity markets as aggregators of demand side resources using a bi-level approach’, IEEE Trans. Power Syst., 2018, 33, pp. 397–411.
-
-
70)
-
69. Arent, D., Arndt, C., Miller, M., et al: ‘The political economy of clean energy transitions’ (Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2017).
-
-
1)
http://iet.metastore.ingenta.com/content/journals/10.1049/iet-esi.2019.0062

Related content
content/journals/10.1049/iet-esi.2019.0062
pub_keyword,iet_inspecKeyword,pub_concept
6
6
