21st Wind & Solar Integration Workshop (WIW 2022)
Buy conference proceeding
- Location: Hybrid Conference, The Hague, Netherlands
- Conference date: 12-14 October 2022
- ISBN: 978-1-83953-833-9
- Conference number: CP818
- The International Wind & Solar Integration Workshop provides a platform for power system operators, transmission and distribution grid operators, wind turbine and PV component manufacturers, universities and research institutes, and consulting companies to exchange technical and economic developments. The Workshop is part of the renowned Renewable Energy Grid Integration Week that comprises three high-quality conferences on grid integration of renewable energies in one week and attracts participants from all over the world. The primary objective is to stimulate interdisciplinary thinking between industry and research by providing a platform for discussion and for sharing ideas and knowledge regarding the key issues in the field of large-scale integration of wind and solar power. With more than 120 presentations in 30 sessions, the 21st Wind & Solar Integration Workshop that was held from 12-14 October 2022 in The Hague, The Netherlands & virtually offered a broad spectrum of topics ranging from resilience, sector coupling, hydrogen solutions and forecasting to hybrid power systems and micro grids. Grid Forming was again a focal point of the 2022 workshop edition with 3 sessions exclusively dedicated to the topic.
1 - 20 of 90 items found
-
Transmission reform in the US
- Author(s): D. Lew ; D. Stenclik ; R. Deyoe ; B. Tsuchida ; L. Lam ; J. Grove ; A. Bigelow ; D. Mueller ; S. Adhikari ; A. Bloom
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
1
(1)
In this paper, we report on two analyses that support the need to reform processes for transmission and generator interconnection planning in the US. The first develops methodologies to quantify the multiple benefits of transmission and applies these methodologies in two sample transmission projects. Using 40 years of weather data, a methodology is developed to examine resilience to extreme weather events. Extensive sensitivity analysis is conducted across renewable energy and fossil-fuelled generator levels, gas prices, and load growth rates, to examine risk mitigation. Loss-of-load expectation analysis is used to examine resource adequacy benefits. Adjusted production cost, emissions, and enablement of high-quality renewable resources are also quantified. These methodologies are applied to two types of example transmission projects in ERCOT (Electric Reliability Council of Texas) to demonstrate a value-stacking approach. The second investigates cost savings for new generator interconnections through a proactive planned approach. A proactive planned approach can study larger numbers of projects or even look forward to anticipate projects due to public policies and may be able to right-size transmission facilities for the longer term rather than sequentially building many small facilities. In this analysis, we compare generator interconnection costs across three different levels of proactiveness in MISO (Midcontinent ISO) and SPP (Southwest Power Pool) to understand the importance of a proactive, planned approach for generator interconnection.
-
Grid forming and grid following comparison for an offshore wind farm connected via a HVAC cable
- Author(s): R. Alves ; A. Egea-Àlvarez ; T. Knuppel
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
9
(1)
Due to the more constant and strong wind resource and an improvement in offshore infrastructures, wind turbines are being positioned further offshore. Although for distances longer than 80-100 km HVDC cables are usually preferred for the transmission system, this paper presents a study which considers a wind farm aggregated model connected to the onshore electrical grid via a HVAC export cable. Two converter control strategies are compared, a grid forming (GFM) and grid following (GFL) units, to identify and quantify any advantage and challenges that the GFM technology might have. These controllers are compared in terms of frequency and time domains considering different power and voltage operating points. Power and voltage steps, polezero maps and disk margins are the frequency studies chosen to compare robustness and stability. A time domain assessment is performed to study the impact of both controllers with regards to voltage sag and frequency drops. Further, an analysis of different grid strengths was performed. The GFM controller has shown to be more robust to all kinds of disturbance and grid strengths
-
Design considerations and test results of a grid-forming dual-fed WTG
- Author(s): D. Howard and S. Achilles
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
17
(1)
Grid-forming inverter-based resources are gaining attention as a viable mechanism for supporting significantly higher penetration of renewables as conventional synchronous generators are being retired or displaced in bulk power systems [1]. Because grid-forming resources emulate some of the physical characteristics of synchronous machines via control algorithms, this technology may help alleviate growing concerns related to decreasing inertia and reducing system strength in power grids. This paper is related to recent technology development of dual-fed wind-turbine technology with grid-forming capability.
-
Offshore network development plans for Europe – joint efforts
- Author(s): A. Orths
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
21
(1)
The European offshore RES strategy from November 2020 aims at 300 GW offshore wind capacity being installed by 2050 in European waters, with the first 60 GW by 2030. Since then, groups of several countries and European Regions joined forces on political level to agree on joint ambitions, as the task is too big to tackle on national level.
In summer 2022, a new European Regulation has entered into force, organizing joint infrastructure planning for the European sea basins, as this is crucial to achieve the ambitions. The new TEN-E regulation EU 2022/869 requests that new offshore network development plans for each European sea basin are to be produced for the three time-horizons 2030, 2040 and 2050. This must be a joint effort of Governments, ENTSO-E and the European Commission, each having to solve a part of this task.
This article describes how ENTSO-E and its member TSOs jointly prepare for solving this task and what is deemed necessary for a seamless international development across waters, mainland, energy systems and energy sectors. Multilateral TSO investigations of possible pathways are addressed, including projects currently under development.
-
Offshore energy hubs: cost-effectiveness in the Baltic sea energy system towards 2050
- Author(s): M. Koivisto ; P. Kanellas ; R. Bramstoft ; H. Koduvere ; J. P. Murcia Leon
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
24
(1)
Offshore energy hubs connect large amounts of offshore wind to a hub from where the generation can be transmitted to onshore, potentially linking to multiple surrounding countries. The benefits of such hubs, and the related meshed offshore grid to connect them, have been investigated in the North Sea. The system-wide impacts of offshore energy hubs in the Baltic Sea are less studied; however, the region is seeing increased interest in offshore wind development. This paper uses detailed offshore wind generation simulations and energy system optimisation to investigate the cost-effectiveness of offshore energy hubs in the Baltic Sea in different scenarios towards 2050. The results show that the largest deployment of offshore energy hubs occurs when the energy system is highly electrified. The strongest development of the offshore energy hubs occurs in the southern part of the Baltic Sea.
-
Frequency-domain stability study of converter-based power systems
- Author(s): J. Sun ; L. Hiquiana ; B. Lee ; J. Schmall ; S. Zuloaga
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
30
(1)
This paper introduces a methodology to study converter-based power system stability using immittance-based frequencydomain models. The approach is based on modeling individual converters by their impedance and admittance (collectively referred to as immittance) measured at their grid interfaces. Together with network immittance, they enable a system model to be formulated in the frequency domain for stability study. The immittance-based models capture system dynamics from subsynchronous to EMT (electromagnetic transient) frequency range, thereby overcoming the limitations of fundamentalfrequency models used in traditional power system studies. The method is a generalization of the impedance-based stability analysis method for individual converters connected to the grid. It can be applied to ac, dc and hybrid ac-dc power systems with any number of converter-based resources. The paper reviews the method and use a practical wind power system to demonstrate the applications.
-
Analysis of transient stability of generator groups in the future power system
- Author(s): D. Scheifele and H. Lens
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
38
(1)
Transient stability is an essential property of electrical power systems. It describes the ability of the system to maintain synchronous operation of all generators. Classically, transient stability of individual generators is analyzed based on possible loss of synchronism after near short-circuit faults. In contrast, this paper considers transient stability of generator groups as a potential instability phenomenon in future grid scenarios. We investigate and analyze relevant factors of influence and countermeasures and modeling aspects to consider when studying the phenomenon. Based thereon we discuss the effectiveness of possible countermeasures. The main focus of this paper is to provide a better understanding of the underlying dependencies within the power system and their impact on the stability itself.
-
Utilisation of synchronous condensers for improved damping in power systems with high renewable penetration
- Author(s): A. Karisik and T. Bertes
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
44
(1)
With ever increasing variable renewable energy (VRE) and subsequent displacement of conventional synchronous generation (CSG), system strength and inertia have been steadily declining in power system grids around the world. A mitigation to the aforementioned problem is installation and operation of synchronous condensers (SC) for provision of system strength and inertia.
While the synchronous condenser is a mature and proven technology, the technology has not been fully utilised, particularly in its ability to provide additional damping to system inter-area modes via Power Oscillation Damper (POD) controllers. Synchronous condensers can provide inertia and modulation of terminal reactive power and voltage (via the excitation system) to impact the system power flows such that it can provide a positive contribution to system damping.
This paper examines the implementation of a synchronous condenser in conjunction with a POD, in a network with high renewable generation, to dampen inter-area modes. Firstly, we investigate a method to determine the ideal location and monitoring Bus of a synchronous condenser, for damping of inter-area modes. Subsequently, the inertia time constant and POD settings are optimised to provide adequate modulation of the SC terminal voltage and reactive power for increased damping of interarea modes. Finally, large and small-signal disturbances are considered with and without the POD to demonstrate the device effectiveness.
-
The opportunity of grid-forming converters in the wide-area control of power systems
- Author(s): R. Musca ; E. R. Sanseverino ; G. Zizzo ; G. Giannuzzi ; C. Pisani
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
51
(1)
In conventional wide-area control schemes, the actuators are typically the power system stabilizers of synchronous machines. The control action, in this case, can not directly act upon the power-angle relationship of the machines. In this context, the gridforming control for power converters offers the opportunity of an effective wide-area control: grid-forming converters present in fact a direct formulation of the power-angle control law, and therefore the possibility of directly acting upon it. The paper proposes an extension of the grid-forming control, including a specific additional control action based on a remote frequency signal. The proposed concept is proved with a simple representative system, and then demonstrated with two application cases, the standard IEEE 39-bus system and the European power system. The results indicate that the proposed participation of grid-forming converters in the wide-area control leads to a considerable improvement of the dynamic characteristics of the system.
-
Towards standardised testing procedures for inertia provision of grid forming inverters
- Author(s): N. Schäfer ; S. S. Kulkarni ; G. Arnold ; V. V. Balani Mahtani
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
59
(1)
Grid Forming (GFM) Inverters and their capabilities are critical to enable growing penetration of Distributed Energy Resources (DER) into the electrical grid. The electrical inertia brought by GFM inverters to the network can replace or supplement the inertia of rotating machines that is a key element for power system stability. The German research project “Netzregelung 2.0” (“Grid Control 2.0”) investigated the operation of power systems with GFM inverters and developed inverter controls and possible grid code compliance testing approaches. First outcomes regarding the testing approaches for inertia provision are presented. A major portion of grid-forming control approaches can be described following the well-known equations of synchronous machines and thus can also be characterized in their frequency behaviour with reference to the first order swing equation of a rotating system, mainly characterized by the acceleration time constant (Ta) and damping (D). The accurate determination of these values is important for system operators and future ancillary service markets. Measurements were performed based on existing and upcoming standards and guidelines with a special focus on parameter determination and measurement uncertainty.
-
Comparison of current-limitation approaches for grid-forming converters enabling fault-right-through operation in converter-driven power grids
- Author(s): J. Struwe ; P. Hackl ; H. Wrede ; R. Schürhuber
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
67
(1)
This paper addresses the issue of limiting currents of grid-forming converter systems in the event of a grid fault. Because power electronics are not capable of feeding in an unlimited amount of fault current, the control method must ensure that the current limits are not exceeded. The most trivial approach is to switch to current-controlled mode in case of a grid fault. This makes the fault current very easily controllable but can also lead to instabilities under certain circumstances, as this work shows. A second approach, which allows the grid-forming properties to be kept, is compared. The simulation results are obtained through experiments in a Hardware-in-the-Loop (HIL) test system. The analysation of the results yields to a better understanding of requirements for grid-forming current limitations for Fault-Right-Through (FRT) operations.
-
On the low risk of SSR in type III wind turbines operating in grid-forming control
- Author(s): W. Yan ; S. Shah ; V. Gevorgian ; P. Koralewicz ; R. Wallen
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
74
(1)
We have shown in previous work that the risk of subsynchronous resonance (SSR) between wind power plant with Type III wind turbines and a series-compensated transmission line is low when the wind turbines are operated in gridforming mode, instead of the standard grid-following mode. This paper explains the fundamental mechanism behind the improved damping characteristics by modeling the positive- and negative-sequence impedances of Type III wind turbines in gridforming control mode. It is discovered that the grid-forming control naturally acts against the negative resistance behavior of Type III wind turbines at subsynchronous frequencies that results from an interaction between the rotor-side converter current controller and negative slip. The developed sequence impedance models and improved damping behavior are verified using PSCAD simulations of a 2.5-MW Type III grid-forming wind turbine. The modeling predictions are also supported by experimentally measuring the sequence impedance response of a 2.5-MW Type III wind turbine in grid-forming control mode.
-
Power quality in a solar-wind hybrid park - preliminary results from a one-year metering campaign
- Author(s): D. Lingfors and O. Lindberg
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
80
(1)
A concern from a grid owner perspective is how so-called hybrid power park (HPP) will influence the power quality (PQ) in their distribution grid. This project studies how PQ and on-load tap-changer operations are affected by a solar-wind HPP located in a Swedish municipality. PQ measurements were performed in ten-minute intervals during 2021 for relevant PQ parameters in wind and photovoltiaics (PV) power parks and a low-voltage substation all connected to the same 10/130 kV transformer and compared to two other load-dominated transformers. Results show that 'events' (i.e., deviations from PQ standards) were more common when measured at the connection points of the parks (130-132 events) than in a than in a load-dominated transformer (70 events). Events are slightly more likely when PV power generation dominates. However, only a few (sag) events may require the grid operator to act. Overall there are less tap changing operations in the transformer in which the HPP is connected compared to in a load-dominated transformer. This is probably due to a broader bandwidth in the tap-changer of the HPP transformer, which may cause future problems downstream. In conclusion, the grid operator should presently not be worried that the HPP will increase PQ issues.
-
Hydesign: a tool for design and operation of renewable hybrid renewable plants
- Author(s): K. Das ; J. P. Murcia Leon ; H. Habbou ; C. Assaad ; J. - A. Pérez-Rúa ; R. Zhu ; P. E. Sørensen
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
85
(1)
With increasing interests for utility-scale renewable hybrid power plants, there is a definite need for new tools for optimal design and operation of these plants for future demanding energy markets. This paper investigates the available tools which can be useful for design of hybrid power plants and mapping the limitations and gaps for these tools. This paper also demonstrates the features and capabilities of a new open source tool HyDesign developed for design and operation of renewable hybrid power plants.
-
Industrial flexibility options: regulatory framework of the European procurement of system services
- Author(s): E. Zipperling ; C. Möller ; M. Zdrallek ; F. Schmaltz
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
92
(1)
With the shutdown of conventional power plants as part of the decarbonisation of the energy system, new capacities for system services are needed. Therefore, according to the EU's Electricity Balancing Guideline from 2017, Demand Response is to be integrated non-discriminatorily into the joint European mechanism for procurement of system services, which is currently being developed.
In Germany, the procurement of system services was last adjusted in 2020, so that flexibility options available at short notice can participate recently. This offers a new marketing option for industrial flexibility options. Expected revenues in this balancing energy market are higher than in the continuous intraday market. Nevertheless, the introduction of the balancing energy market has not fulfilled its objective of increasing competition and the costs for balancing energy are immense. However, complex analyses are necessary for optimised marketing in the balancing energy market, compared to the intraday market, where the attractiveness of flexibility marketing is also increasing.
In this paper, it is shown, that the prequalification mechanism for participation in the german energy balancing markets is currently too high, a hurdle for industrial demand response. Within the framework of European procurement, it must be possible to intensively integrate modern virtual power plants.
-
Did wind cause the price rise in European electricity market in 2021? - an econometric analysis using multi regression model of spot market prices
- Author(s): Y. Yasuda
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
100
(1)
The recent price rise in European electricity markets was not begin from the Russia's invasion of Ukraine but has gradually arisen during 2021. In the autumn of 2021, many media argued as if the cause of the price rise were low wind. This paper evaluates these arguments are appropriate or not by an economic empirical analysis. Since a simple linear combination model in MRA (Multiple Regression Analysis) is not necessarily infer causality between explanatory variables and an explained variable, ERM (Extended Regression Model) in STATA is employed in this study. Also, using a counterfactual method, a quantitative evaluation of DOI (Degree of Influence) are performed to several European market including Denmark, Germany, France and Spain. The results revealed that no scientific evidence could be found to prove the argument that low wind caused the price rise in electricity spot market.
-
Stakeholder engaged energy systems modelling: three Canadian case studies
- Author(s): M. McPherson
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
106
(1)
Meeting Canada's emission reduction targets requires a fundamental shift, not only in the infrastructure underpinning the supply and delivery of energy services, but also in the institutional frameworks that govern policy and investment decisions. Stakeholders' engagement in the energy transition is gaining momentum, but a communication gap between experts and decision makers is impeding the impact of model-based decarbonization analyses. This represents a substantial missed opportunity. We present three case studies that adopt a two-pronged strategy to co-create and co-deliver model-based insights. The first prong entails the development of an integrated energy modelling suite that provides a holistic perspective of energy systems that spans sectors, spatial-temporal scales, and energy vectors. The second prong entails a model implementation process, in which stakeholders and researchers co-develop 'Scenario Bundles' to analyze a particular project, policy, or target through a series of collaborative activities. We present three case studies, at the federal, inter-provincial and municipal scales respectively, that apply these two prongs in distinct stakeholder-driven modelling projects. We conclude with a critical analysis of the role of modelling and stakeholder engagement in effective decision making.
-
New pathways to future grid compliance for wind power plants
- Author(s): G. M. Gomes Guerreiro ; F. Martin ; G. Yang ; B. Andresen
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
115
(1)
Over the last decade, the rapid growth of wind power is driving an increase of efforts in defining the frameworks and rules for the connection of wind power plants (WPPs) through the grid codes and standards, making testing/validation more demanding and complex for wind turbine (WT) manufacturers and WPP developers. Traditionally, WT manufacturers carry out grid compliance tests at full-scale prototype turbines whereas WPP developers and Transmission System Operators (TSOs) mainly perform studies for new WPPs based on offline RMS and EMT simulations. Until now, these strategies have been sufficient for ensuring grid compliance of WTs and WPPs, however moving forward the wind sector needs new testing methods to meet the increasing WT capacity, WPP complexity, and deployment pace to achieve society's desired sustainability targets. In this paper, the emerging strategies that target these challenges are presented as: a) subsystems and component testing of WTs specified in IEC 61400- 21-4; b) - hardware-in-the-loop (HiL) real time simulation for WT/WPP control and protection appraisals (future 61400-21-5). Finally, a future outlook is given on the importance of addressing model validation and how these strategies can be complemented with other modern analytical tools such as artificial intelligence/machine learning, data-driven dynamic modelling, digital twin technology, and software-in-the-loop (SiL) real time simulation.
-
Towards full electrical certification of wind turbines on test benches - experiences gained from the HiL-GridCoP project
- Author(s): F. Hans ; G. Curioni ; T. Jersch ; G. Quistorf ; M. Ruben ; A. Müller ; C. Wessels ; C. Fenselau ; I. Prima ; J. Lehmann
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
122
(1)
In recent years, more and more wind turbine manufacturers have been using test benches, such as the Dynamic Nacelle Testing Laboratory at Fraunhofer IWES in Bremerhaven, to test and optimize their turbines. To further accelerate the test phases, Fraunhofer IWES, together with the project partners Nordex Energy SE & Co. KG and Vestas Wind Systems A/S, has built a new test bench for grid compliance testing of reduced systems, consisting of the generator, the converter, and the transformer plus control as well as protection system. The HiL-GridCoP project demonstrated the comparability of test bench measurements on a wind turbine equipped with a doubly-fed induction generator with field measurements performed using a fault ride-through container. The aim of this paper is to present some of the key findings related to the electrical commissioning and test execution. The focus is on the grid simulator and on its impedance simulation functionality. It is discussed which limitations may be caused by specific test bench components and which issues might affect the test results. Finally, some measurements of voltage dips are presented to verify the test bench's comparability with field tests so that the full electrical certification can be carried out next.
-
Temporary overvoltages and their impact on grid security - final results from the joint research project OVRTuere
- Author(s): S. Kaiser ; S. Eichner ; C. Wirtz ; M. Murglat ; M. Brenner ; P. Lilje ; C. Garcia ; J. Döll ; Y. Ayadi ; E. Bosch
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
130
(1)
The stability and security of electricity grids is of central importance for society and the economy. One potential technical risk, which grid operators have been giving increasing attention, is that of the potential large-scale tripping of generation plants due to temporary overvoltages. This paper makes recommendations about dealing with temporary overvoltages in the German power system, taking the increasing displacement of synchronous machines by inverter-based plants into consideration.