Applied Building Performance Simulation
2: No Affiliation
Good building performance is contingent on complex, interacting factors. The application of performance simulation tools allows practitioners to adopt a virtual prototype and test approach in selecting design solutions that balance performance and cost.
The aim of this book is to provide guidance on approaches to the modelling and simulation of energy systems in the built environment at various scales and complexities to address the myriad challenges of the clean energy transition. The intention is to equip the reader with the understanding required to compose high integrity models, commission realistic simulations, and interpret predictions to assess life cycle performance and ensure operational resilience.
Initial chapters introduce the impressive capabilities of building energy systems simulation and the new features that are likely to be added in future. The authors then describe the sustainable energy challenge and how modelling and simulation can be used to scrutinise proposals in a cost-effectively manner. The remainder of the book then covers different technology options including electrification of heating, net zero energy housing, community energy systems, active demand management, and urban energy action planning. In each case the nature of the problem is described, the construction of a high-fidelity computer model elaborated, and principal simulation outcomes demonstrated.
Some of the problem domains addressed in the book are accompanied by a high-fidelity digital model available externally. These models are compatible with the ESP-r performance simulation program, which is freely available under an open-source licence.
Applied Building Performance Simulation provides a thorough grounding and practical guidance in the role of software simulation tools for building performance, for an audience of researchers, industry professionals, advanced students, and policy makers, regulators and standards bodies operating in the field.
- Book DOI: 10.1049/PBBE002E
- Chapter DOI: 10.1049/PBBE002E
- ISBN: 9781839531651
- e-ISBN: 9781839531668
- Page count: 690
- Format: PDF
-
Front Matter
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
(1)
-
1 Sustainable energy systems challenge
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
1
–19
(19)
This chapter outlines the contextual challenges that give rise to the need for high-resolution performance modelling and simulation. These challenges correspond to the various aspects underpinning government policy and regulations, the competing technical solutions that might be brought to bear, and the often conflicting requirements of stakeholders.
-
2 Building performance simulation
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
21
–77
(57)
This chapter summarises the BPS+ tool functionality required to address the issues introduced in Chapter 1 and the actions required to apply the approach effectively in practice.
-
3 Performance assessment requirements
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
79
–125
(47)
Whilst it has long been recognised that building performance is a multi-variate problem domain (Markus et al. 1972), it is only with the advent of performance simulation that the issue can be adequately addressed at the design stage.
This chapter describes some of the assessments and ratings that are used to evidence acceptable performance and demonstrate compliance with building regulations. In some cases, equations are given to enable BPS+ outputs to be mapped to indices that are not included in a specific program or to support a comparison with what might have been calculated otherwise.
-
4 Application in practice
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
127
–207
(81)
This chapter describes the issues to be confronted when applying BPS+ in new design or retrofit situations and identifies opportunities for simplifying the process in contrast to the high-resolution modelling examples of the next chapter. The contention is that such simplifications can introduce the use of a simulation approach in a non-demanding manner that is helpful for the novice.
-
5 High-resolution modelling and simulation
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
209
–244
(36)
This chapter makes the case for a computational approach to design based on high-resolution models that support holistic, multi-variate appraisals of performance over extended periods and under a range of conditions likely to be experienced in practice. Although such an approach is not routinely practiced at present, it could become widely accepted if it was demonstrated to be better, cheaper, and quicker than the present fragmented approach to design/upgrade stage options appraisal. The chapter that follows then summarises a wide range of applications, in some cases following judicious simplifications applied to an otherwise high-resolution input model.
-
6 Example applications
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
245
–376
(132)
BPS+ models are highly adaptable and may be applied to a wide range of problem types from new build and refurbishment to component design and air quality appraisal. This chapter has summarised problem types and scales that characterise the potential. In most cases, the projects were serviced by ESRU software applications that were under development at the time and so could be adapted rapidly in response to exposed deficiencies. Because these applications serve as a platform to research the issues underpinning the computational approach to design, they remain objects of ongoing refinement. They are made available at no cost under an open-source licence in the hope that others will contribute to the refinement process and application in practice.
-
7 Urban energy schemes
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
377
–406
(30)
This chapter considers the application of BPS+ in support of community energy schemes whereby technologies for energy generation are co-located with demands as a means to attain improved resource utilisation. Whether and where this approach is generally viable has yet to be proven.
-
8 Regional/national scale energy action
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
407
–422
(16)
This chapter takes the Parametric Energy Profile Analysis (PEPA) procedure of Section 7.7 and generalises it further to make it applicable to very large building stocks (e.g., national) where specific property details are not available. Reducing energy demand on a large scale and replacing conventional energy sources requires that policymakers comprehend the large variation in systems and behaviours across the stock as well as the uncertainties underpinning upgrades and energy supply options. This chapter explores the application of BPS+ to devise strategies for building stock upgrades at the regional or national scale. This requires the generation of BPS+ input models in a manner that bypasses the need to consider buildings individually, given the unacceptable data processing effort that would otherwise be required. It also requires the application of BPS+ to explore innovative solutions for sectors such as agriculture and water management.
-
9 Smart grids with active demand management
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
423
–441
(19)
This chapter addresses the concept of a smart grid (Kamran 2022) defined as an electricity supply network that uses digital communications technology to detect and react to local changes in demand and supply. The issues to be considered within a BPS+ simulation include demand management/response, supply asset dispatching, active network control, accommodating behaviour change, appliance selection, and design for operational resilience. BPS+ has evolved to a level that can address these issues and thereby enable a balance to be struck between the requirements of consumers and network operators.
-
10 Urban energy systems deployment
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
443
–457
(15)
BPS+ tools are normally applied by professionals to provide information in support of design decision-making. In this mode of operation, outputs are scrutinised and considered before being passed on as recommendations to clients. The impact can be amplified where outputs are used to inform policy and urban action planning. This chapter considers the extension of BPS+ to include the deployment of sustainable energy systems within urban environments requiring site selection that respects local policy and technical constraints. The factors underlying policy and technical decision-making, and the scoring and weighting factors to be applied, can be elicited from city planners and utility personnel and used to identify urban sites that are policy unconstrained and technically feasible. This chapter reports the form of a Geospatial Opportunity Mapping tool, named GOMap, which operates alongside BPS+ to quantify the energy potentials of urban energy systems deployment.
-
11 Tackling the performance gap
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
459
–499
(41)
There can be many reasons why BPS+ predictions do not match reality and consequently fail to deliver design stage expectations - the so-called performance gap (de Wilde 2014). This chapter considers some principal causal factors that can be accommodated within a high-resolution model as required in specific cases. These include design parameter uncertainty, occupant behaviour, operational events, and construction defects.
-
12 Virtual world to reality
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
501
–542
(42)
This chapter considers the use of BPS+ within building upgrade schemes and the subsequent extraction of data aspect models in formats that support the off-site manufacture of building components. It also addresses the use of BPS+ in support of real-time control and facilities management, and as a low-cost replacement for physical prototype testing. Finally, it speculates on the future role of artificial intelligence and the possibility of design appraisal in near real time. The ultimate aim is to support an extension of the application capability of BPS+ in both scale and depth (Clarke 2015).
-
13 Strategic renewables
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
543
–566
(24)
The world is not running out of energy resources although there are diminishing options that are deemed acceptable in many jurisdictions. From an energy planning perspective, the future need not be viewed in a negative manner as something that is too uncertain to enable informed action: it should be viewed as an opportunity. Simulation offers a practical way to improve upon what has gone before by planning for a more integrated energy system at all scales.
This chapter considers the possibility of establishing large-scale renewable energy assets in a manner that complements matched loads located nearby or remotely distributed but synchronised. To this end, BPS+ can be used to determine the load profiles of target communities (local, remote, existing, or planned) and size corresponding renewable energy technology (RET) installations. In the latter case, this might entail the use of a commercial package such as PVsyst or a free package such as RETScreen in cases where a BPS+ tool does not offer such a modelling feature. This chapter summarises the nature of supply-side models and indicates how they can be utilised to complement BPS+. The presented models, although rudimentary, are considered suitable for inclusion in BPS+ to provide first-order estimate of the available renewable resources. The models correspond to assessment methods as taught by Energy Systems Research Unit (ESRU) staff to students in the Renewable Energy Systems and the Environment MSc course at the University of Strathclyde. Three technologies are briefly covered corresponding to tidal stream, wind, and solar power capture.
-
14 Conclusions and future perspectives
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
567
–573
(7)
Some three decades ago, the Latham report (Latham 1994) recognised the chronic shortage of skilled workers within the construction industry, identified a lack of training and education, and called for team working within a process of continuous improvement. Such shortages are still apparent, and upskilling of the construction workforce remains a major challenge to improve the quality of future buildings and ensure the proper installation of new and renewable technologies. BPS+ provides a cost-effective means to improve productivity. It does this by amplifying user intellect to allow complex problems to be analysed in a timely and rigorous manner. In addition, it supports distributed team working on projects of any scale.
-
Appendix A: Theoretical basis of ESP-r
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
575
–593
(19)
ESP-r is a multi-physics modelling tool, which is primarily focused on modelling the performance of the built environment. The generic nature of the tool allows considerable latitude in application scale and detail - for example, to represent explicitly a thermostat, a computer monitor, a vehicle, or a portion of a ship as well as buildings at variable levels of detail. It holds a super-set data model supporting multiple domain solvers as well as acting as a repository for the descriptors needed by third-party tools.
-
Appendix B: Model file organisation and data quality assurance
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
595
–614
(20)
BPS+ tool vendors have adopted different approaches to model content organisation. EnergyPlus, for example, contains model data in a single Input Definition File (IDF) and, along with weather data files and a separate folder for simulation results, presents this to the user via a conceptually simple layout as shown in Figure B.1.
-
Appendix C: Example ESP-r automation script
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
615
–622
(8)
The following scripts should be considered in conjunction with the description given in Section 4.5.
-
Appendix D: Material properties
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
623
–637
(15)
This appendix presents the outcome of a review of existing datasets of thermophysical properties of building materials and an assessment of data reliability in terms of the underlying test procedures (Clarke and Yaneske 2009).
-
Appendix E: Knowledge-based user interfaces
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
639
–647
(9)
As the construction industry becomes more assertive in its demands of BPS+, it is likely that high on the agenda will be the harmonisation of user interfaces. This will help regularise training at all levels and ensure that users can switch between applications as required.
-
Back Matter
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
(1)