Distribution Switchgear
This book is an invaluable reference source dealing with the general principles of the switchgear function and discussing topics such as interuption techniques, fault level calculationsm switching transients and electrical insulation.
Inspec keywords: electromagnetic forces; fault currents; switchgear testing; overhead line conductors; power cables; quality control; switchgear insulation; power distribution faults
Other keywords: overhead conductor connected secondary switchgear; interruption technique; distribution switchgear; symmetrical fault current; switchgear type test; service problem resolution; quality control; insulation; cable connected secondary switchgear; electromagnetic force; high voltage fuse links; contact design; switching transient; asymmetrical fault current; primary switchgear
Subjects: Switchgear; Insulation and insulating coatings; Power system protection; Inspection and quality control; Distribution networks; Overhead power lines
- Book DOI: 10.1049/PBPO046E
- Chapter DOI: 10.1049/PBPO046E
- ISBN: 9780852961070
- e-ISBN: 9781849190572
- Page count: 262
- Format: PDF
-
Front Matter
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
(1)
-
1 Basics and general principles
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
1
–8
(8)
This chapter focus on basics and general principles of switchgear. A fundamental question is the type of question that children specialise in asking, and, in order to respond correctly and fully, you have to give the subject more thought than would otherwise be the case. My grandchildren specialise in these sorts of thought provoking questions and, as I am sure that all readers are familiar with the function of gooseberry bushes, I shall confine myself to try to address the fundamental question 'Why do we have switchgear?'. Certain electrical distribution customer's senior engineers used to go out of their way to say that switchgear was a necessary evil. It cost money to buy, install and maintain and that it did not earn any revenue. This is clearly an oversimplification as the end user only buys electrical power, so anything that makes that possible must contribute to that end. These customer's engineers did, however, concede that switchgear was necessary to isolate equipment that became faulty, and they could allow the system to be split into sections to allow quick restoration of power supplies. While electricity distribution systems are relatively passive, for example, the situation in a factory, particularly one using manufacturing processes, or in a generating station can be active, the switchgear takes a critical part in controlling what is taking place. So, switchgear is needed: (a) to isolate faulty equipment; (b) to divide large networks into sections for repair purposes; (c) to reconfigure networks in order to restore power supplies; and (d) to control other equipment.
-
2 Interruption techniques
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
9
–30
(22)
If we put to one side fault current interruption using high-voltage fuses, interrupting mediums used in medium voltage distribution switchgear today are oil, vacuum and SF6 gas. There is a small percentage of units based upon hard gas, where the arc is forced into contact with materials that generate a gas to work on the arc and air break technology based upon cold cathode or insulated metal plates. However, techniques such as these are now very rare and will not be considered here. Oil interruption technology is no longer used for new primary switchgear applications, but, although in declining numbers, it is still used extensively within secondary switchgear. As the total population of circuit breakers is currently still dominated by oil interrupting types, it is important that the mechanism for arc interruption in oil is understood.
-
3 Fault level calculations
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
31
–42
(12)
This chapter presents the calculation of short circuit currents when fault occur in the electrical distribution network. When planning a new installation, or modifying an existing installation by adding in a transformer or making a cable connection to another substation, the effect on the fault level needs to be determined. This is to ensure that the installed plant will still be within its rating and will be able to carry and interrupt the fault current safely. There are a number of specialist companies, and some software packages available, to carry out these calculations but a practising engineer should be able to determine the likely fault level at the feasibility stage.An example of a very simple fault level calculation follows, where there is only one element of impedance. You will notice that in the calculations the network impedance upstream from the transformer is ignored, as this will have a very small value is also discussed in this chapter.
-
4 Symmetrical and asymmetrical fault currents
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
43
–54
(12)
In the previous chapter, we saw how to calculate the symmetrical fault current. This is important from the RMS heating point of view, but for distribution switchgear engineers, the asymmetrical current is of much greater importance for a number of reasons that will be discussed in this chapter. The rate of rise of current is higher under symmetrical fault conditions but the peak current of a fully asymmetrical fault current will induce the maximum electromagnetic force, and therefore stress, on conducting components. In addition, the total contact loading, which is the sum of electromagnetic and spring loading, must be sufficient to prevent contact burning. A fully asymmetrical current, as it is offset, will consist of major and minor loops. The time between current zeros in a major loop will therefore be greater than that implied by the power frequency of the system. This will induce greater stress on the interrupting system being used and, therefore, must be proven by test.
-
5 Electromagnetic forces and contact design
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
55
–70
(16)
It is a fundamental phenomenon of electricity that a force is exerted between conductors carrying electrical current. Under normal load current conditions, these forces are very small, however, many engineers will not be aware of the enormous forces that are generated when the normal current is replaced by a short-circuit current which can be 40-50 times larger in magnitude. This force generated phenomenon forms the basis of many desirable aspects of electrical engineering, such as the operation of measuring instruments and electrical motors, but in switchgear these forces are potentially dangerous in terms of the stresses induced in both the conductors and their supporting insulators. Two factors influence the magnitude of the electromagnetic force that will be experienced. These are the strength of the magnetic field and the current flowing. The field strength can be derived from Laplace's Law. This states that the field strength created at a point in space due to the passage of electric current through a conductor is inversely proportional to the square of the distance between that point and the conductor, and is directly proportional to all other factors. The force experienced by a conductor in a magnetic field is derived from Biot-Savart's law in that the force is proportional to the flux density and the length of the conductor.
-
6 Switching transients
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
71
–86
(16)
A circuit breaker, when it closes or opens its contacts in an electrical circuit, causes energy stored within elements of the circuit to be redistributed over a very short period of time. During this period, voltages and currents can be produced which are far in excess of those which are normally present when the circuit is experiencing steady-state conditions. The levels of transient current and/or voltage produced during disturbance of an electrical circuit are of vital interest to those who design electrical systems because, without taking preventive or protective measures, damage to the circuit elements may take place. In the case of complex, highly reactive circuits, the calculation of transient overvoltage generation by circuit breaker switching operations can be difficult to evaluate without resorting to transient analysing equipment. However, there are specialist companies that will carry out system studies that are able to show, with great accuracy, the abnormal conditions that could be expected. Figure 6.1 shows an example of the type of result that can be produced. In this case, the results of a study of switching overvoltages are shown. It will be noted that the transient voltage disturbance had a duration of about three cycles. This duration would have been reduced had the circuit contained more resistance.
-
7 Insulation
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
87
–102
(16)
It is obvious that conducting components within distribution switchgear have a high voltage potential difference both interphase and with respect to earth when in service. These components have to be securely mounted and fixed in position by using materials which are very poor conductors of electricity. These are known as insulating materials and form a range of components that are continually stressed throughout the whole life of the equipment. It is certain, therefore, that latent defects within insulating materials, due to inadequate selection, design or manufacture, will manifest them selves during the life of the equipment. It follows, therefore, that great care must be taken when designing insulation systems that are to be incorporated within distribution switchgear. Insulating materials are, by definition, very poor conductors of electricity, which is why they are used to cover conductors, give support to busbars and other conductors, and, in a gaseous form, are used to fill compartments to provide both insulation and a dry, clean environment.
-
8 Operating mechanisms
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
103
–118
(16)
It is the function of a circuit breaker operating mechanism to transmit stored energy via a mechanical drive to the moving contacts, so as to cause them to close and open, when commanded, within defined operating times and speeds. What is more, it should operate without hesitation even after prolonged periods of inactivity. Operating mechanisms will incorporate drives to ancillary devices such as auxiliary switches for remote control and indication, motor drives for spring charging, position indicators and local manual trip and close facilities. In many cases, an operations counter will also be required.
-
9 Primary switchgear
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
119
–134
(16)
This chapter discussed the primary switchgear which is the first stage in the process of conducting electrical power from the grid to the end user. The importance of the strategic position of a primary substation and its switchgear within the system means that the layout, design and operation must ensure maximum availability and reliability.
-
10 Cable connected secondary switchgear
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
135
–152
(18)
This chapter presents the function of cable connected secondary switchgear to accept electrical power from a primary switchboard. The secondary switchgear then distributes the power to points in the network where the voltage is either transformed to a lower value or where it is consumed without transformation, as would be the case when supplying high-voltage machines.
-
11 Overhead conductor connected secondary switchgear
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
153
–174
(22)
Because of the relatively high cost of electrical distribution by buried cable, power supplies to sparsely populated areas are invariably provided by overhead line conductors. The present-day overhead line distribution equipment is the product of innovation and evolution resulting from many years of application in the field of rural electrical distribution. Advances in technology, as they have become avail able, have been adopted to provide better security and continuity of the supply of power to remote centres of consumption, as well as providing the power supplier with information which was not readily available a few years ago.
-
12 High-voltage fuse-links
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
175
–186
(12)
High-voltage current limiting fuse-links are widely used for the protection of distribution cables and transformers. They commonly form part of fuse-switch combination units, or in some cases they are used as stand-alone devices to provide the sole protection of equipment. Their particular advantages are their low first cost, their small dimensions and their ability to limit the peak fault current and let-through energy of a short-circuit fault to a small fraction of the prospective value. Well-designed fuse links can limit the fault energy to around one 500th of what a conventional circuit breaker would let through. High rupturing capacity (HRC) fuse-links, therefore, give the applications engineer the opportunity to limit the damage which would otherwise result in the event of a short-circuit fault. The disadvantages of the HRC fuse-link include the necessity of stocking and carrying spare fuses and the need for manual intervention to replace a fuse, or fuses, in the event of a fault. In addition, unlike a circuit breaker, they are unable to detect zero sequence currents and, therefore, they will not operate on an earth fault that has a magnitude which is less than the rating of the controlling fuse-link. However, many of the applications for controlling transformers and cables in secondary electrical distribution circuits successfully employ HRC fuse-links.
-
13 Switchgear type tests
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
187
–210
(24)
It is not the purpose, or possible, within the scope of this book to provide a detailed step-by-step guide on the procedures to be followed when conducting development and type testing of switchgear. Indeed, such a guide would run into several volumes and, due to detailed changes in specifications that take place from time to time, it would quickly become obsolete. It would also have to cover all types of switchgear including circuit breakers, switches, fuse switches, fuses, earth switches and disconnectors. However, the intention here is to give an overview of the important stages in testing that have to be completed in order to provide switchgear that is safe and able to operate correctly in the circuits and ambient conditions for which it is intended. By way of example, particular reference will be made to circuit breakers. The opportunity will be taken to highlight certain aspects of each type test in order to show the relative importance and the way in which solutions to encountered problems can, and usually will, have an influence on the performance of other type tests.
-
14 Product conformity, quality control and service problem resolution
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
211
–220
(10)
As it is neither practicable, nor economically feasible to type test every production circuit breaker or switch, instead, manufacturers are confined to carrying out inspections, measurements and certain limited tests, on a routine basis, to confirm that every production unit is identical to the unit that was type tested.
-
15 Cost of ownership
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
221
–224
(4)
The cost of switchgear ownership can be very much greater than simply the initial capital cost of purchasing the switchgear. Some accountants are only interested in the expenditure within a current financial year. However, it could be argued that this first cost will only be a small percentage of the total cost of ownership over the lifetime of the switchgear. The true cost of ownership should include the cost of the substation, as different types of switchgear will occupy different volumes of substation space and, therefore, influence the overall substation cost. In addition, costs will be incurred for the erection, installation and commissioning of the switchgear. Once the switchgear is installed, other costs will be incurred, such as maintenance, labour, materials and outage time. Finally, disposal at the end of useful life must be considered. For example, SF6 switchgear will incur disposal costs, as only specialist companies have the facilities necessary to safely dispose of the equipment without risk to personnel and without contaminating the atmosphere. Conversely, disposing of oil and vacuum switchgear at the end of their life will generally be self-financing or even yield a small profit. All of these costs combine to give the true lifetime cost of ownership.
-
16 The future
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
225
–230
(6)
In this chapter, a significant proportion of problems with distribution switchgear involve parts that move, solid state switching held out the prospect of a brand new circuit breaker having no moving parts and no contact erosion. However, the ratings available of back-to-back solid state devices such as Triacs were such that a large number of devices had to be used connected in series and parallel in order to reach usable distribution voltages and current ratings. Voltage sharing of series connected devices needed shorting capacitors and the heat produced by the forward voltage drop meant that oil cooling with circulation pumps would be necessary. A costing exercise was carried out and this showed that a solid state circuit breaker would cost about ten times the price of a conventional distribution circuit breaker having the lowest usable rating.
-
17 Further reading
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
231
–234
(4)
This chapter lists sources of information which will assist the reader to search and explore aspects of switchgear in greater depth.
-
18 National, International and customer Specifications
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
235
–240
(6)
As specifications are under continuous review, everyone associated with the design, manufacture, application and operation of switchgear should ensure that they consult with the latest edition of a relevant specification. They can verify this by checking the yearbook of the standards organisation. If they do not do this, then there is a danger that they will not comply with tenders or standard operation instructions and may put themselves into an illegal situation. The following standards are listed for guidance only and the yearbook should be consulted to ensure that the copy being used is up to date.
-
Back Matter
- + Show details - Hide details
-
p.
241
(1)